« Verizon's Latest Dumb Idea | Main | Google Error Highlights Data Entry Problem in Industry »
Why MagicJack Fails for Business VoIP
It claims to be the fastest growing phone company in the U.S. but I don't recommend it for business. After it crashed during my latest interview (you'll see the story next Wednesday), I decided to contact help and ask for a solution to the problem. I expected little because MagicJack gets a failing grade for support from Broadband Reports' GBU rankings.
Here's the chat transcript.
Cartman: Hello, how may I help you?Alexander Goldman: magicjack crashed during a call.
Alexander Goldman: I use windows xp
Cartman: I see..
Cartman: Thank you for addressing your concern.
Cartman: May i know when did this issue started.
Alexander Goldman: it happened today
Cartman: May i have your magicjack number please.
Alexander Goldman: 718 705 0625
Cartman: Thanks
Alexander Goldman: also voip error handling not good
Alexander Goldman: in 203 area code, instead of a busy signal, the magicjack just hangs up without a message
Cartman: On your magicJack, click menu and volume/headset control. Can you toggle between telephone and headset there?
Alexander Goldman: I can. but I use computer system sound, not headset
Alexander Goldman: I mean, I use telephone, not headset
Cartman: Okay...
Cartman: Please try connecting your magicJack to a different USB port and try again.
Alexander Goldman: I reconnected it to the same USB port but I have not made a call
Cartman: Please try using a different phone with your magicJack.
Alexander Goldman: i connected to another USB port. why would the phone crash the magicjack. do you have real solutions to this problem or just a script.
Cartman: http://www.speedtest.net
Cartman: Please click the link then click the pyramid of your location.
Cartman: Kindly give me the speed test result of your internet bandwidth both on download and upload speed per kbps.
Cartman: Thanks.
Cartman: Please go to the "Menu" on your magicJack, click "Headset/Volume Control" and lower the volume for both microphone and speakers to about 1/3 of max.
[I pass the test and]
Cartman: Please go to the "Menu" on your magicJack, click "Headset/Volume Control" and lower the volume for both microphone and speakers to about 1/3 max
Alexander Goldman: will this solve problem?
Alexander Goldman: volume is already 1/3 max
They tried to blame my ISP, my PC -- anything but their own service. I hung up.
I won't even try to get the problem of the instant-hangup-on-dial solved or the various other issues with the service. I'm worried that's it's difficult to uninstall.
I will say this, however. Having obtained just over a full year of service for about $60, MagicJack was a bargain for me and for Jupitermedia.
Lately, however, I've been forced to take calls on my home phone, the POTS line, so it's time to change to a more reliable service. I see several possibilities on the GBU list. Do you have any suggestions?
Update 1: MagicJack has contacted me and I will talk to them soon.
Update 2: Additional Links (thanks Peter):
Wednesday, October 01, 2008 Real Problems With Magic Jack .... Is Majic Jack Hiding Something? How to uninstall Magic Jack from your PC





Leave a comment